What's wrong with this picture?

As a child (and even as an adult, truth be told), I rather enjoyed the “What’s wrong with this picture?” on the back of Highlights magazines. There is a picture with several humorous “impossibilities” or “extremely unlikely” nuances, for instance, a fish walking a dog. Or a car with a doughnut wheel. Or a fire hydrant spitting out grape juice.

When looking at the school district, there are several things that just seem wrong. Unfortunately, they are far more serious.

The NG put out three aritcles recently about AYP Scores (taken from the extremely helpful NIU Illinois Interactive Report Card):

Obviously, there is something wrong with this picture. Can you find all of them?

I have been talking about “reform” recently. When I read these kinds of articles and hear about the frustrating experience teachers face with NCLB, I have two thoughts:

  1. If NCLB is hurting us so much, what are the positives that balance it out? Surely, there must be a balance because nobody in power wants to get rid of NCLB, and of course, D.C. would never ever do anything that didn’t make sense.
  2. If the evidence shows that certain folks do not test well, what are we going to do about it?

To the latter, I have a strong desire to be very active. The former…. at this point in time, that whole realm is just overwhelming to me, rather out of my league.

As to addressing underperforming lower SES kids, I continue to be heartened by reports of Garden Hills’ Homework Club and Stratton’s Wednesday evening afterschool program. Why don’t we do more of that? Why don’t we invest (and it truly is an investment) a much higher percentage of our resources to helping out those kids? I know, I know, I hear it already – “That’s not fair!!” Yes, I realize that proud parents of super genius kids (and also the not-too-far-behind wannabees) want “what’s best” for their precious ones. I get that. They want access to technology, the best curriculum, the best teachers, the best school. I also have heard about this thing called “White flight” and the more general concept of well-to-do families and parents with means sending kids to other (more expensive, not “free”) schools. What exactly defines “fair”? That is not an argument I wish to get into right now. But I do like to hear opinions, so feel free to speak up. 🙂

Back to the point. Either we need to change the tests, or change the focus of our efforts. I prefer both. I have always hated standardized tests, and I continue to look for viable alternatives. (Trying to offer constructive criticism means I need to work on building up and not just tearing down.)  In a recent thread, there is the idea of allowing kids to be grouped on ability or skill level, not age. I am convinced that the “best” road is not the “easy” road. In fact, at this point in time, I am almost convinced that the “easy” road is never the “best” road. Embracing the wide range of children, all with different strengths and abilities, is a messy, onerous, time-consuming, inefficient, labor-intensive task. And yet, at the core of my heart, I believe that is exactly what we should do.

How? I laugh when people ask me this. Because I am no expert, I have not studied this issue, I hold no degree in anything Education. From my naive perspective, it would seem to me that we need to start with community engagement. Increase the number of mentors and tutors, not by 100%, but by factors (ie, LOTS!). Drastically reduce the size of classes. Take the time to evaluate kids on an individual basis. Find their strengths and capitalize on that. Find their weaknesses and gain their cooperation in addressing them. Teach kids life skills. Heck, teach kids how to be involved in their children’s education! We were never taught that.

There are lots of folks, acting alone or in small contexts, already living out their passion to help the underprivileged. There are many stories happening all around us. Many good stories. Go out, find them, become one.

</soapbox>

Advertisements

3 Responses to “What's wrong with this picture?”

  1. charlesdschultz Says:

    And a completely different angle, from The Associated Press:
    http://www.news-gazette.com/news/education/2011-10-31/illinois-grade-school-achievement-gap-narrowing.html

    “Illinois’ latest standardized test results show that the achievement gap among elementary school students is narrowing, largely because of gains among black, special education and low-income students, the Illinois State Board of Education announced Monday.”

    So… is this a case of “every coin has two sides”?

  2. mom2cne Says:

    It isn’t in all subjects and it is done within grade levels but our school has implemented a really great reading program that addresses the fact that not all kids are at the same place. They divide up into groups based on their reading level and it allows all the kids, from those who need intensive help to read at all to those who are reading dramatically above grade level to get instruction at their level. They just started it last year, but it seems like it is very successful, so far. I would like to see it implemented in other subjects, but I understand that the moving from class to class and testing and benchmarking and everything that goes along with it is very time consuming.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: